Answer to December 2008 Newsletter Brain Teaser:

The answer is 1/2 or a 50% chance. Here's how:

Let p(x) denote the probability that the xth passenger finds his/her seat occupied when coming on board the plane.

When the first person gets on board, his seat is definitely NOT occupied. so...

p(1) = 0

The second person will find his seat occupied if the first guy took it, and the probability of that is 1/100. so...

p(2) = 1/100

The third person will find his seat occupied if EITHER the first guy occupied it OR the second guy occupied it. so...

p(3) = 1/100 + p(2).1/99

Arguing similarly, let's p(4) and p(5):

p(4) = 1/100 + p(2).1/99 + p(3).1/98
p(5) = 1/100 + p(2).1/99 + p(3).1/98 + p(4).1/97

You should now see a pattern emerging:

p(2) = 1/100
p(3) = p(2) + p(2).1/99
p(4) = p(3) + p(3).1/98
p(5) = p(4) + p(4).1/97
....
....
p(x) = p(x-1) + p(x-1).1/(100-x+2)
....
....
p(100) = p(99) + p(99).1/2

Infact, it's easy to see why we get this pattern. Think about what happens when person 'x' boards the plane. That depends on what happened when the (x-1)th person boarded the plane. EITHER the xth seat was already occupied OR the (x-1)th person occupied the xth seat because the (x-1)th seat was taken.

We know that the probability that the (x-1)th seat was occupied when person 'x-1' got on board is p(x-1). THE KEY IS to realize that the probability that the xth seat was occupied at that time is also, infact, p(x-1). Why? Because every occupied seat had the same likelihood of getting picked (because people chose their seats at random if their seats were taken). If we add the two probability in the EITHER/OR case in the preceding paragraph, we get the formula:

p(x) = p(x-1) + p(x-1).1/(100-x+2)

Anyway, the rest is easy.

Simplifying our final pattern, we get the following:

p(2) = (1/100)
p(3) = (100/99).p(2)
p(4) = (99/98).p(3)
p(5) = (98/97).p(4)
...
p(100) = (3/2).p(99)

Since each probability is > 0, we can safely multiply all the terms on either side and we get:

p(2).p(3)...p(100) = (1/100)(100/99).(99/98).(98/97)...(3/2).p(2).p(3)...p(99)

Canceling numerators & denominators on the right side and p(2).p(3)...p(99) on either side, we get:

p(100) = 1/2.

So, the probability that the 100th guy sits in his/her own seat = 1 - p(100) = 1/2.


Home | Register | Courses | Course Locations | In-House Seminars | Consulting Services | 2012 Schedule

Newsletter | Video Commentary | Radio Shows | About Michael Gasior | Mike's Blog | Alumni | Links | Contact Us

 
AFS Seminars LLC: 500 Chamberlain Hill Rd. : Middletown, CT 06457-5564
Tel: (860) 347-6568
Fax: (860) 347-6258
 
Material Copyright © 2012 AFS Seminars LLC